1) How bad would it be to lose it?
If the answer is ‘bad’ then you absolutely must have at least two copies.
If the answer is ‘terrible’ then at least three copies is wise. At least one should be in a safe place off site. Incremental backups are better than basic ones, since files do get corrupted and vanish.
Ideally, you want both up to date incremental backups and complete snapshots taken at regular intervals and checked periodically for integrity.
2) How bad would it be if it ended up all over the internet?
If this would be a problem at all, there is a whole universe of precautions to consider:
Hardware: firewalls, built in encryption, air gapped systems and storage, networking hardware (including WiFi), etc
Software: cryptography, operating systems, malware risks (including pirated software), intrusion detection systems, etc
Behaviour: physical access control, data retention and destruction, passwords and secret questions, backup processes
Digital data is the sort of thing where not only can the cat get out of the bag, but it can get out, get copied a billion times, and become your name’s top Google hit for the rest of your life.